Here we go again. There is another government bailout on the horizon, commercial real estate. It begs the question: When are we going to get to an industry that is not "too big to fail"? There is an article this morning in the Wall Street Journal, "Office Rents Slide on Drop In Demand", that contains a great lesson to be learned by those who invest in commercial real estate. The article summarizes how "commercial property investors who paid top dollar for office buildings in recent years, relying on easy credit and projections of continued rent growth." are going to pay the ultimate price if they cannot figure out a way to refinance the debt on these projects. And with this, industry executives have asked the federal government for help.
OK, go ahead ask; when is enough, enough?? When do we stop rescuing people that told us all not to worry because they were smarter than the rest of us?
Enough. Here is the lesson. Too much debt on a real estate investment just adds unnecessary risk on top of the risk inherent in investing in real estate. Vacancy rates for office buildings have risen from a national average of 12.2% a year ago to 14.4% now. Proper underwriting of a project should account for such increases and have some cushion built in to account for them. If a 2.2% rise in vacancies sinks the industry then we who invest in real estate deserve whatever happens to us. The one fact left out of this article is that office vacancies have returned to 2005 rates. In the last three years vacancies have been between 11-14% nationally, not much change in the fundamentals in this period of easy money. Of course there are markets, such as Detroit, in trouble with 20% vacancies and my simple example using national average is not 100%, but I think it makes a very interesting point. The commercial real estate industry is in trouble because of the lure of easy money and big returns due to high debt. Shame on those who chased that shinny lure only to be hooked.
Hopefully the federal government will stay out of this one and let the real estate market correct on its own. The economy will always have a cloud hanging over it until someone isn't "too big to fail".